Thought LeadershipNovember 11, 20268 min read

The Answer Every Contractor Gives

Warren Sukernek, a fractional CMO for HVAC and home services contractors, explains why a specific position wins the call and the follow-through wins the job.

By Robert Puharich with insights from Warren Sukernek
The Answer Every Contractor Gives | Warren Sukernek




A CONTRACTOR IN CHICAGO once gave Warren Sukernek the answer most contractors give when asked what sets them apart. He had been in business for 25 years and answered calls around the clock. His company had 500 Google reviews, a reputation for trust, and well-trained technicians.



It was a respectable list, but it could have come from the contractor around the corner, or from the one around the corner from him. So Sukernek kept asking. What was this contractor really good at? What was unique about the business? And why was he good at it?



The answer came from the weather. “It gets cold here in Chicago,” the contractor said, and, in all his years of experience, he had never met a boiler he couldn’t fix. It was a narrower claim than anything on his first list, and the first one to name a place, a season and a piece of equipment. It’s what made him different from the rest.



They explored it further, and it became his position: the boiler expert of Chicago, backed by a guarantee along the lines of some money back if he couldn’t fix the boiler.



Sukernek advises HVAC and home services contractors on positioning and growth, and that exchange shows how he approaches it. A specific position gives a homeowner a reason to call. What happens after the call is a second test, and it’s where he sees many contractors lose ground.



A Business Built on Sameness



Sukernek calls the problem “the sea of sameness,” and he has written about it extensively. In his view, the contractor business, like more or less any trade, is somewhat of a commodity, because a contractor is not servicing a product of their own. Techniques follow the manufacturers and the products, and technicians have often trained and worked elsewhere, so the contractor doesn’t wholly own the process.



The result is a market where, in his words, “Many trades companies look the same, and they speak the same. The trucks are mostly white with blue block letters, and everyone fishes in the same pond.”



A Customer in a Hurry



HVAC is also a reactive business. A typical homeowner doesn’t think about a furnace or heat pump unless there is a problem, so most calls come in summer or winter, when it is very hot or very cold, and the equipment isn’t working. Replacement is expensive, and nobody wakes up planning to spend thousands of dollars on an air conditioner that day.



The pain drives them toward a rash decision, whereas a $15,000 vacation, Sukernek points out, would be a lot more deliberate and researched. They have to make an uncomfortable decision fast.



The Test Every Claim Has to Pass



The first thing Sukernek asks a contractor is what makes the company different, and why a homeowner should call. The answers tend to repeat. Years in business, around-the-clock service, hundreds of reviews, trusted and well-trained technicians. His reasoning is plain. The contractor around the corner says it too, and so does the one around the corner from him.



That points to a test any owner can run. Take the claim and ask whether a competitor could say the same thing. If so, ask what the company is really good at, and why it is good at it, and keep asking until the answer gets specific.



In Chicago, specific meant boilers. It also matched the kind of call a contractor there gets when the weather turns cold and the equipment stops working. Set beside 25 years in business and calls answered around the clock, it was a different kind of statement. The first could be made by any contractor in town. The second belonged to only one of them.



Then came the guarantee. Anyone can say they have never met a boiler they couldn’t fix, but a promise of money back if the boiler couldn’t be fixed puts the contractor’s own word on the line.



Sukernek wants contractors to stand out and differentiate themselves “throughout the entire customer journey so that they’re memorable.” The position is where that starts, and the rest of the journey is where it gets proven.



The First Few Minutes



Many of the owners Sukernek meets are already spending money to get customers to call. They often tell him they have an agency and still can’t tell what is driving their bookings. His answer is usually to fix the process before spending more on leads, and he starts with what happens when someone reaches out.



A business owner can answer a web form quickly if they sound interested in the homeowner’s or the business’s project. Or it can be answered whenever somebody gets around to it. Each one leads to different results.



Sukernek counts slow or missing responses among the biggest problems many contractors face, and his advice is to be “easy to do business with.” That first impression, he says, goes a long way in winning the business. His playbook for contractors sets a two-hour limit to return any missed calls or web forms.



The Estimate Nobody Follows Up On



When Sukernek evaluates a contractor’s marketing, one of the first questions is how big the customer list is and how often anyone uses it. Typically, he finds it is the company’s best asset and the most underutilized. The list includes people who filled out a form or did business with the company in the past and were never engaged again.



Open estimates are the most immediate part of it, so he asks how often anyone follows up. Without a defined follow-up process or workflow, he says, the customer is unlikely to choose you. A blip in your process, and you lose a customer.



What the Customer Sees in the Work



Sukernek’s Contractor Reputation Playbook turns to the job itself. Its analysis of thousands of Google reviews across plumbing, electrical, HVAC, roofing, and garage door businesses found that more than 93 percent of negative reviews came from administrative and operational friction, such as communication, pricing, and scheduling, rather than workmanship. In its analysis of 17,241 HVAC reviews, educating the homeowner about the problem outranked speed and price in producing five-star reviews.



The playbook’s version of that is concrete. The technician shows the customer the failed part, whether a capacitor, a contactor, or a cracked pipe, and explains what it does. Then they explain why it failed, in plain language, followed by repair and replacement options with a clear price. They disclose any trip fee before the appointment, and the homeowner agrees to the price before work begins. If the job turns up something unexpected, work stops until the homeowner approves a revised quote.



The visit is just as deliberate around the edges. Arrival windows shrink from four hours to two, and a text goes out with the technician’s photo and an ETA map. The visit ends with the cleaned site, shoe covers removed, and the system tested together with the customer before anyone signs off.



Taken together, the findings suggest the repair itself is rarely what customers complain about. How it is explained, priced, and scheduled is where the playbook says trust is won or lost.



What the Next Customer Finds



The next customer usually starts with a search. A contractor’s Google Business Profile (GBP) is what they see when they look for a contractor near them, and it is a living document. Many contractors, Sukernek says, set their GBP and forget it. Without service areas, services, project photos, reviews, and replies, it goes dormant. It also feeds Local Service Ads and is a source that AI search tools like ChatGPT draw on, so a neglected profile makes a contractor less likely to appear in either.



This is where the work in the house shows up again, because every review is a customer’s account of a visit. In his own business, Sukernek says referrals bring his best clients because credibility arrives before the first conversation. A strong profile can do some of that work for a customer who has no one to ask.



A Check for This Week



The check is short, and it comes straight from Sukernek’s questions. Ask what makes your company different, and notice whether the contractor down the road could say the same thing. If so, ask why your company is good at what it does and keep asking until the answer gets specific. Then review the open estimates and make sure you follow up on each one more than once. Check how long a web form waits for an answer, and when the Google profile was last touched.



What surprised Sukernek most in HVAC was how many contractors share the same problems and solutions. He found that the most successful ones are the ones that have been unique. He encourages contractors to step outside how they have always done things and learn from other businesses and industries.



In Chicago, the distinctive answer was already there. It took one more question to find it.






Warren Sukernek: Global B2B marketing executive and fractional CMO with 20+ years of experience spanning international product-line brand positioning, customer insights and advisory communities, product commercialization, and digital transformation. Combines firsthand HVAC channel knowledge with leadership across multinational technology, industrial services, supply chain and B2B businesses. Translates market research and structured customer feedback into differentiated positioning, product roadmaps and measurable growth; MBA in Finance and Operations.





About the author:


Robert Puharich is the founder of IsleFlow Content Studio Inc. and author of Building Brilliance. He helps construction firms build the trust, authority, and credibility that makes them the first call, not just another bid.



IsleFlow Content Studio Inc. logo